Children in developing countries have deep deficits in math and language. Personalized coaching for teachers has been proposed as a way of raising teacher quality and child achievement. We designed a coaching program that focused on one aspect of teacher quality—teacher-child interactions—that researchers in education and psychology have argued is critical for child development and learning. We implemented the coaching program in Ecuador, with 100 1st grade teachers randomly assigned to treatment and 100 to control. Coaching improved the quality of teacher-child interactions but reduced child achievement. Our results underline the importance of evaluating new forms of professional development for teachers, even those that follow best practice, before these interventions are taken to scale.
Authors

Research Fellow University College London
Pedro is a Professor of Economics at University College London and an economist in the IFS' Centre for Microdata Methods and Practice (cemmap).

Yyannú Cruz-Aguayo

Norbert Schady

Ruthy Intriago

Sarah Schodt
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.47004/wp.cem.2022.0522
- Publisher
- The IFS
Suggested citation
Carneiro, P et al. (2022). When promising interventions fail: personalized coaching for teachers in a middle-income country. London: The IFS. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/when-promising-interventions-fail-personalized-coaching-teachers-middle-income-country (accessed: 10 February 2025).
Grant
Related documents
More from IFS
Understand this issue

Share of apprenticeship budget spent on each apprenticeship level
The proportion of funding directed to higher-level apprenticeships (level 4 and above) has trebled between 2017–18 and 2021–22 from 13% to 39%.
16 January 2025

The school funding challenges awaiting the new government
5 July 2024

Levelling up: it’s time to step up
30 June 2024
Policy analysis

Projecting options for 16–18 education spending per student after 2025, 2009–10 = 1
To maintain spending per student at 2025–26 levels, total funding would need to rise by almost £200 million in today's prices by the end of 2027–28.
16 January 2025

The distribution of deficits and surpluses across English colleges
Although there has been some improvement since 2017, 37% of colleges reported operating in deficit in 2022–23.
16 January 2025

Public spending on adult education and skills (actual and projected for 2024–25)
Public funding for adult skills has declined significantly since its peak in the early 2000s.
16 January 2025
Academic research

Changes in marital sorting: theory and evidence from the US
Measuring how assortative matching differs between two economies is difficult, we show how the use of different measures can create different outcomes
27 November 2024

Call for papers: IFS-ADBI-GHE Workshop on Health Economics in LMICs 2025
Submissions are open until 15th February for the IFS-GHE Workshop on Health Economics in LMIC 2025

Survey of the Ghanaian Tax System
This edition of the Survey of Ghana’s Tax System provides a comprehensive overview of the tax system as of the start of 2024.
18 November 2024