Downloads

WP202239-What-drives-wage-stagnation-monopsony-or-monopoly.pdf
PDF | 864.63 KB
Wages for the vast majority of workers have stagnated since the 1980s while productivity has grown. We investigate two coexisting explanations based on rising market power: 1. Monopsony, where dominant firms exploit the limited mobility of their own workers to pay lower wages; and 2. Monopoly, where dominant firms charge too high prices for what they sell, which lowers production and the demand for labor, and hence equilibrium wages economy-wide. Using establishment data from the US Census Bureau between 1997 and 2016, we find evidence of both monopoly and monopsony, where the former is rising over this period and the latter is stable. Both contribute to the decoupling of productivity and wage growth, with monopoly being the primary determinant: in 2016 monopoly accounts for 75% of wage stagnation, monopsony for 25%.
Authors
Shubhdeep Deb
UPF Barcelona

Research Associate Pompeu Fabra University and Barcelona Graduate School of Economics
Jan is an IFS Research Associate, a Research Professor at the Barcelona School of Economics and an ICREA Research Professor at the UPF Barcelona.
Aseem Patel
University of Essex
Lawrence Warren
US Census Bureau
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2022.3922
- Publisher
- Institute for Fiscal Studies
Suggested citation
Deb, S et al. (2022). What drives wage stagnation: monopsony or monopoly?. 22/39. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/what-drives-wage-stagnation-monopsony-or-monopoly (accessed: 20 May 2025).
More from IFS
Understand this issue

Drastic times need drastic action: breaking the 50-year tax taboo
Rachel Reeves should consider increasing the basic rate, just as Denis Healey did in 1975
14 April 2025

Rank of local authorities by average household income compared to rank by average consumption after housing costs
On average, London local authorities rank at the top of the income distribution, but are bottom of the net-of-housing consumption distribution.
11 April 2025

How can we make government more productive?
How can the public sector do more with less? We explore productivity trends, government reform and lessons from private sector innovation.
3 December 2024
Policy analysis

Combined impact of minimum wage and tax increases may reduce opportunities for young people
Upcoming increases in the minimum wage and employer NICs could make it harder for young people entering the labour force.
1 April 2025

Working in your 60s: a way to stay young for some
On average, women who remained in work for longer following increases in the state pension age saw improved cognition and less physical disability.
13 May 2025

Here’s a pension tweak for nudging civil servants to work past 60
Public sector pension rules are a mess that helps neither workers nor the government. Fixing them could be a win-win.
28 April 2025
Academic research

The menopause "penalty"
We show that a menopause diagnosis leads to lasting drops in earnings and employment, alongside greater reliance on social transfers.
21 March 2025

The impact of labour demand shocks when occupational labour supplies are heterogeneous
We develop a tractable equilibrium model of the labour market with heterogeneous labour supply elasticities by occupation and across occupation pairs.
8 April 2025

Market concentration and productivity: evidence from the UK
We measure product market concentration and business dynamism in the UK from 1997 to 2020 and study the relationship with productivity.
6 May 2025