We study how social proximity between the sender and the receiver of information shapes the effectiveness of preventive health behaviour campaigns and the persistence of misinformation. We implement a field experiment among a representative sample of slum residents in two major Indian cities characterized by Hindu-Muslim tensions. We show that informative messages are effective at improving evidence-based behavior, but not non-evidence-based behavior. These findings do not differ by social proximity, signalled by religion. However, when sender and receiver share the same religion, the intervention significantly reduces misinformation carrying in-group salience, highlighting the role of social proximity in fighting misinformation.
Authors
Associate Director
Britta is an IFS Associate Director, Associate Staff at the Department of Economics at the UC and Researcher at NIHR Obesity Policy Research Unit.
Research Fellow Nova School of Business and Economics
Alex is an IFS Research Fellow, an Associate Professor at Nova School of Business and Economics and a Research Affiliate at the CEPR.
Senior Research Economist
Antonella Bancalari is a Senior Research Economist at the Institute for Fiscal Studies.
Kalyan Kumar Kameshwara
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2022.1822
- Publisher
- Institute for Fiscal Studies
Suggested citation
Armand, A et al. (2022). Social proximity and misinformation: experimental evidence from a mobile phone-based campaign in India. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/social-proximity-and-misinformation-experimental-evidence-mobile-phone-based-campaign (accessed: 24 January 2025).
More from IFS
Understand this issue
What is the case for carbon taxes in developing countries?
Carbon pricing can be a powerful tool for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. What are the risks and opportunities from such policies in developing countries?
4 November 2021
Gender norms, violence and adolescent girls’ trajectories: Evidence from India
24 October 2022
Policy analysis
Wealth-related taxes in low- and middle-income countries
IFS Research Fellow, Laura Abramovsky, delivered the presentation at an online meeting of officials from the BMZ and GIZ.
17 May 2024
Three ways to improve the design of the UK’s overseas aid spending target
18 January 2024
Distributional analysis of Ghana’s tax system
18 December 2023
Academic research
Call for papers: IFS-GHE Workshop on Health Economics in LMICs 2025
Submissions are open until 15th February for the IFS-GHE Workshop on Health Economics in LMIC 2025
Prediction sets and conformal inference with censored outcomes
This paper provides estimation methods of such prediction sets given observed conditioning covariates when 𝑌 is censored or measured in intervals.
21 January 2025
Individual welfare analysis: Random quasilinear utility, independence and confidence bounds
We introduce a novel framework for individual-level welfare analysis.
13 December 2024