Downloads

wp2107.pdf
PDF | 486.19 KB
Income Tax and National Insurance are now sufficiently similar that merging them appears to be a plausible option, yet still sufficiently different that integration raises significant difficulties. This paper surveys the potential benefits of integration - increased transparency and reduced administrative and compliance costs - and the potential obstacles, assessing the extent to which each of the differences between Income Tax and NICs - in particular the contributory principle, the levying of an employer charge and the differences in tax base - constitute serious barriers to integration. The paper concludes that few of the difficulties look individually prohibitive, but that trying too hard to avoid significant reform of the current policy framework could produce a merged tax so complicated as to nullify much or all of the benefits of integration.
Authors

Senior Economist
Stuart is a Senior Economist working in the Tax sector, and focuses on analysing the design of the tax and benefit system.

Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2007.0721
- Publisher
- IFS
Suggested citation
Adam, S and Loutzenhiser, G. (2007). Integrating Income Tax and National Insurance: an interim report. London: IFS. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/integrating-income-tax-and-national-insurance-interim-report (accessed: 13 July 2025).
More from IFS
Understand this issue

Paul Johnson’s final episode: big challenges ahead for the UK economy
In Paul's final episode, he speaks with incoming IFS Director Helen Miller about the big economic pressures facing the UK.
9 July 2025

Spending Review 2025: What it means and why it matters
We take a closer look at the Spending Review and what the policies mean for public services, investment and the wider economy.
12 June 2025

Why is the government reforming health-related benefits?
We discuss the government's welfare reforms aimed at helping sick and disabled people into work, and what the changes mean for health-related benefits
14 May 2025
Policy analysis

Rachel Reeves will need to face up to fantasists on both sides
The chancellor has to somehow reconcile tax and spending, but both her own Labour MPs and the Tory opposition are still living in a dream world
7 July 2025

The Pensions Review: final recommendations
We provide concrete recommendations to improve the UK pension system to secure better standards of living for future pensioners.
2 July 2025

Labour’s first year in power: is this still a mission-driven government?
Join the Institute for Fiscal Studies and the Institute for Government to discuss Labour's first year in power.
Academic research

Focal pricing constraints and pass-through of input cost changes
I prove that, in a simple but general framework, expected pass-through is unchanged by the presence of focal pricing constraints.
10 July 2025

Manuel de l’estimation du coût d’une politique fiscale
Introduction à l’estimation du coût d’une politique fiscale: Un manuel et des exemples pratiques
8 July 2025

Tax equity in low- and middle-income countries
In this paper, the authors ask what role taxation can or might play in reducing inequality in low and middle-income countries.
2 July 2025