We study the identification of panel models with linear individual-specific coefficients when T is fixed. We show identification of the variance of the effects under conditional uncorrelatedness. Identification requires restricted dependence of errors, reflecting a trade-off between heterogeneity and error dynamics. We show identification of the probability distribution of individual effects when errors follow an Autoregressive Moving Average process under conditional independence. We discuss Generalized Method of Moments estimation of moments of effects and errors and construct non-parametric estimators of their densities. As an application, we estimate the effect that a mother smoking during pregnancy has on her child's birth weight.
Authors

Research Fellow Centre for Monetary and Financial Studies (CEMFI)
Manuel is a Research Fellow of the IFS and a Professor of Econometrics at CEMFI, Madrid.

Professor of Economics University of Chicago
Journal article details
- DOI
- 10.1093/restud/rdr045
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press
- Issue
- Volume 79, Issue 3, July 2012
Suggested citation
Arellano, M. and Bonhomme, S. (2012), 'Identifying distributional characteristics in random coefficients panel data models'79(3), https://doi.org/10.1093/restud/rdr045
More from IFS
Understand this issue

Drastic times need drastic action: breaking the 50-year tax taboo
Rachel Reeves should consider increasing the basic rate, just as Denis Healey did in 1975
14 April 2025

Average household consumption spending before and after housing costs, and mean weekly per-capita income, in different local authorities, 2018–2019
Londoners may have the highest average incomes, but their household spending once you account for housing costs is lower than other regions.
11 April 2025

Rank of local authorities by average household income compared to rank by average consumption after housing costs
On average, London local authorities rank at the top of the income distribution, but are bottom of the net-of-housing consumption distribution.
11 April 2025
Policy analysis

Here’s a pension tweak for nudging civil servants to work past 60
Public sector pension rules are a mess that helps neither workers nor the government. Fixing them could be a win-win.
28 April 2025

Today’s ONS figures highlight uncertainty around fiscal forecasts
Public finance data out today show that borrowing overshot the official forecast made at last month's Spring Statement by £15 billion.
23 April 2025

Which places have the highest standard of living?
Measuring living standards using average household spending gives a starkly different picture of regional inequalities than using average income.
11 April 2025
Academic research

Why do couples and singles save during retirement? Household heterogeneity and its aggregate implications
We find that most households save more for medical expenses than for bequests but that richer households and couples save more for bequests.
1 March 2025

Does the reference period matter when evaluating the effect of SNAP on food insecurity?
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is the cornerstone food assistance program in the United States.
1 December 2024

Specialised courts and the reporting of intimate partner violence: Evidence from Spain
We assess the effect of the creation of specialised courts on the reporting of IPV (intimate partner violence), and the incidence of IPV in Spain.
1 November 2024