The Timms Review into disability benefits is due to be published later this month. The review’s remit is to examine the existing working-age disability benefit system and make recommendations for reform. This note outlines the background to the review, what the review has said already and what we will be looking out for in the review’s final report. A much fuller discussion of the options for reforming disability benefits can be found here (Latimer, Oulton and Waters, 2026).
What is personal independence payment and how many people claim it?
Personal independence payment (PIP) is the main working-age disability benefit in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.1 Eligibility is based on the extent to which applicants have difficulty carrying out day-to-day activities and getting around. It is not means-tested on income or wealth, nor linked to whether or not the claimant is working or able to work.
Since 2019, the share of 16- to 64-year-olds in England and Wales claiming PIP (or its predecessor benefit) has increased substantially – up from 5.5% in August 2019 to 8.2% in August 2025. This has led to spending on these benefits increasing from £14 billion in today’s prices in 2019–20 (0.5% of GDP) to £25 billion in 2025–26 (0.8% of GDP). Spending is forecast to increase further to £33 billion by 2030–31 (Department for Work and Pensions, 2026a; Office for Budget Responsibility, 2026). Disability benefits now make up a much greater share of total benefit spending on working-age adults and children – 21% now, compared with 11% in 2015–16.
In response to these trends, the government set up the Timms Review. The review has committed to making proposals that would keep spending at or below current projections, but it is not yet clear whether its recommendations will cut spending or simply hold it steady.
What do we know so far?
The Timms Review has already set out several ‘emerging recommendations’. These recommendations include three key changes to the current system. We look at each in turn – summarising the case for it, the case against it and setting out the questions that the government will need to resolve before implementing any proposals.
Moving to support based on direct assessment of disability-related costs
Under the current system, personal independence payments are based on a points-based assessment of the difficulties people face with daily living and mobility activities. The first major ‘emerging recommendation’ is that payments could instead be based on an assessment of the actual disability-related costs that someone faces.
There are a number of possible advantages of moving to directly measuring costs. First, both the Timms Review and the government have stated that a rationale for PIP is to cover disability-related costs. Currently, the points-based assessment functions as a rough proxy for disability-related costs; a cost-based system would more closely link payments to the benefit’s stated rationale.
Second, linking payments to costs could make the system better at varying awards between people with different disability-related costs. The current system gives people with very different levels of assessed disability the same amount of money. For example, someone who cannot wash themselves and needs assistance dressing their upper body would currently get the same level of support for daily living – £5,960 a year – as someone who cannot wash themselves, cannot dress themselves at all, cannot talk and cannot read. We would expect disability-related costs to vary significantly between these two example claimants, so an approach that sets payments based on measured costs may be more successful at differentiating awards between those with the most severe disabilities and less severe disabilities.
However, there are also risks with this approach. The key risk is that disabled people who face costs that are hard to measure may get less support than those with a similar level of costs, but where those costs are easier to measure. Distinguishing between disability-related and non-disability-related spending is often not straightforward: while a wheelchair clearly falls in the former category, things such as taxis and cleaners may be a necessity for one claimant and a luxury for another. If cost-based support is restricted to only certain items which are clearly disability-related (such as wheelchairs), recipients will not be able to get support for other genuine disability-related costs (such as cleaners for those who are not able to clean their house themselves). Conversely, if a wide range of items is covered, it may be difficult for the government to assess which applicants have a need for them arising from disability.
Questions for the review:
- What costs will be covered?
- How will it be determined that a cost is disability-related, and what framework will ensure that support is targeted at costs that genuinely arise from disability?
- Will awards be based on previous costs incurred or a forward-looking assessment of costs?
- How often will costs be reviewed, given that disabilities, and the support needed to help with them, change over time?
Moving to in-kind support
The second key recommended change to the current system is a move to some awards being partially in-kind. In a recent interim update, the Timms Review recommended that cash should remain ‘the foundation of the award’ but ‘some awards will also include services, and offer other non-cash support’. For example, it might recommend that the government directly provides certain services, such as therapy or particular aids like handrails. There are multiple arguments for moving to a system where some support is provided in the form of services. First, the government may take the view that certain services are more effective at improving disabled people’s lives than cash. Second, restricting awards to services may reduce the incentive for people with low levels of disability to apply as they would not benefit from the additional services. Of course, if the PIP assessment worked perfectly, they would be rejected anyway. But there is imprecision in the PIP assessment, as we discuss here. Finally, the government might be able to provide certain types of support at lower cost than the private market. For instance, local authorities tend to get a cheaper price for social care services than private payers because they buy care services in bulk and so have more bargaining power (Jarrett, 2018).
However, there are also disadvantages to this approach. First, and perhaps most fundamentally, a key advantage of cash is that it allows disabled people to decide which goods or services to buy, and they will likely know best what spending would be most valuable to them. Second, a disadvantage of public provision relative to cash is that – if disabled people were unable to choose an alternative provider – there would be less competitive pressure on providers to supply a high-quality service.
Any additional in-kind support should be designed to be complementary to existing services such as the NHS or social care.
Questions for the review:
- What services will be provided?
- Will claimants be able to choose cash or services or will assessors make this decision?
- How will the new assessment determine who gets services and who gets cash?
Making the assessment process easier and more supportive for applicants
The Timms Review’s emerging recommendations also include measures to improve the experience of applying for PIP. These include better access to reasonable adjustments and advocacy services, more personalised support during the application process and making the application available online. One of the key themes of the Timms Review Interim Report was that many disability benefit applicants find the application process stressful and difficult; these changes would make the process less burdensome for these applicants.
These changes would also likely increase the number of people applying for disability benefits. There is strong empirical evidence that when it is easier to apply for a benefit, more people will apply (Ko and Moffitt, 2022; Deshpande and Li, 2019). The government’s own evaluation of its self-service online trial for PIP, which allowed claimants to submit more of their details online (instead of over the phone) if they wished, found the trial led to a substantial increase in applications especially shortly after rollout (25% more in the first 4 months, and 19% over the first 21 months) and awards (7% in the first 4 months, and 4% more in the first 21 months, Department for Work and Pensions, 2026b). More applications will feed through into more people claiming disability benefits and therefore more spending. Given the review is operating within a fixed cash envelope, it will need to adjust other recommendations to account for the higher costs implied by these changes. It will either need to make the payment amounts lower or eligibility criteria tighter than they otherwise would need to be.
Questions for the review:
- To what extent will changes to the application process increase claimant numbers?
- If a larger number of claimants is expected, how will eligibility criteria be tightened or generosity of support reduced to ensure that the overall package of reforms recommended by the review stays within current projections for disability benefit spending?
What to expect after the review
After the review is released, the government plans to respond to both the Timms Review and the Milburn Review – which recently recommended changes to benefits for 16- to 24-year-olds – in a White Paper early in the new year. You can find our response to the Milburn Review here. We may need to wait until this White Paper is released to get a clearer view of exactly what this government envisions for the disability benefit system. Whatever the government chooses to do, it is clear that both reviews want to see big changes to who receives support and what form that support takes. Delivering on these big reforms without increasing total spending on disability benefits will mean making difficult choices – any decision that gives more support to some inevitably means less support for others.
CLARIFICATION: This comment initially only included estimates of the effects of the DWP digital self-serve trial over 4 months, it has since been edited to include estimated effects over both 4 months and 21 months.










