Unique longitudinal probabilistic expectations data from the Berea Panel Study, which cover both college and early post-college periods, are used to examine young adults’ beliefs about their future incomes. We introduce a new measure of the ex post accuracy of beliefs, and two new approaches to testing whether, ex ante, agents exhibit Rational Expectations. We show that taking into account the additional information about higher moments of individual belief distributions contained in probabilistic ex-pectations data is important for detecting types of violations of Rational Expectations that are not detectable by existing mean-based tests. Beliefs about future income are found to become more accurate as students progress through school and then enter the post-college period. Tests of Rational Expectations almost always reject for the in-school period, but the evidence against Rational Expectations is much weaker in the post-college period.
Authors

Research Fellow University of Michigan
Tom is a Research Fellow at IFS, a Research Professor for the Institute for Social Research at the University of Michigan.

Yifan Gong

Todd Stinebrickner

Ralph Stinebrickner
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2021.0121
- Publisher
- The IFS
Suggested citation
Crossley, T et al. (2021). Examining income expectations in the college and early post-college periods: new distributional tests of rational expectations. London: The IFS. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/examining-income-expectations-college-and-early-post-college-periods-new (accessed: 9 February 2025).
More from IFS
Understand this issue

Share of apprenticeship budget spent on each apprenticeship level
The proportion of funding directed to higher-level apprenticeships (level 4 and above) has trebled between 2017–18 and 2021–22 from 13% to 39%.
16 January 2025

Why are universities in financial trouble?
21 August 2024

Minimum wages in the UK – how high can they go?
In the UK today, earnings inequality is substantially higher than it used to be.
30 October 2024
Policy analysis

Spending per pupil or student per year at different stages of education (2024–25 prices)
This chart compares the trends in public spending per student on various stages of education over time in England.
16 January 2025

The distribution of deficits and surpluses across English colleges
Although there has been some improvement since 2017, 37% of colleges reported operating in deficit in 2022–23.
16 January 2025

Public spending on adult education and skills (actual and projected for 2024–25)
Public funding for adult skills has declined significantly since its peak in the early 2000s.
16 January 2025
Academic research

Changes in marital sorting: theory and evidence from the US
Measuring how assortative matching differs between two economies is difficult, we show how the use of different measures can create different outcomes
27 November 2024

Household responses to trade shocks
We study the impact of Chinese import competition in the 2000s on workers and their households in England and Wales.
12 November 2024

The effects of youth clubs on education and crime
Using quasi-experimental variation from austerity-related cuts, I provide the first causal estimates of youth clubs' effects on education and crime.
12 November 2024