The introduction of competition has frequently been found to cause costs to fall. There has, however, been a question as to whether this was partly achieved at the cost of quality. Auction theory predicts prices would fall more the greater the competition to provide the service. There has been some debate about whether the smaller budgets would make contract compliance more difficult. Evidence is found in support of this hypothesis. We also find some evidence that the better recorded performance of the in-house direct service organisations (DSOs) during this period was due to the information advantage they had from being incumbents.
Authors
Robin G. Milne Milne
Graeme Roy
Luis Angeles
Journal article details
- DOI
- 10.1111/j.1475-5890.2012.00171.x
- Publisher
- Blackwell Publishing
- JEL
- H57; L14; L15; L32;L33
- Issue
- December 2012
Suggested citation
L, Angeles and R, Milne and G, Roy. (2012). 'Competition, Quality and Contract Compliance: Evidence from Compulsory Competitive Tendering in Local Government in Great Britain, 1987–2000' (2012)
More from IFS
Understand this issue
Cuts to council services likely unless cost pressures abate – even with the biggest council tax increases for 20 years
press release
Cuts to some council services are likely unless spending pressures abate, even with big increases in council tax and especially in more deprived areas
21 June 2024
Council funding is a numbers game in which everybody is losing
comment
"Local government finance is a mess that has been years in the making, but good luck trying to solve it." Paul Johnson writes for the Times.
13 May 2024
Council tax needs urgent reform – not being frozen in time in 1991
comment
The Conservatives have ruled out revaluing and reforming council tax in England as part of what they term their ‘Family Home Tax Guarantee’.
6 June 2024
Policy analysis
Conservative plans to abolish the UK Shared Prosperity Fund to help fund a new National Service scheme would hit poorest parts of the UK
comment
Abolishing the UK Shared Prosperity Fund would see poorer parts of the UK lose hundreds of millions in funding – with Cornwall and Wales hardest hit.
29 May 2024
The IFS Scottish Budget Report – 2024–25
report
This report looks at the key budgetary and public service issues for the Scottish Government for the 2024–25 financial year and beyond.
22 February 2024
Scottish Budget: Tax and spending in 2024–25
report
The Scottish Government is raising taxes on the 5% highest-income Scots, but health funding is, on current plans, set to fall in real terms next year.
6 February 2024
Academic research
Unfunded mandates and taxation
journal article
In 2006, the Chinese central government increased civil servant salaries and pensions and used either unfunded and funded mandates in different areas.
14 March 2024
What’s happened and what’s next for councils?
book chapter
We examine what’s happened and what’s next for councils in England and Wales, focusing on the short-term financial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the medium-term financial outlook, and planned and potential financial and service reforms over the next few years.
7 October 2021
Financing local police spending in England and Wales: fiscal federalism in practice
journal article
Since 1995, police forces in England and Wales have been able to raise revenues locally to supplement grants from central government.
21 February 2020