We investigate state‐dependent effects of fiscal multipliers and allow for endogenous sample splitting to determine whether the U.S. economy is in a slack state. When the endogenized slack state is estimated as the period of the unemployment rate higher than about 12%, the estimated cumulative multipliers are significantly larger during slack periods than nonslack periods and are above unity. We also examine the possibility of time‐varying regimes of slackness and find that our empirical results are robust under a more flexible framework. Our estimation results point out the importance of the heterogenous effects of fiscal policy and shed light on the prospect of fiscal policy in response to economic shocks from the current COVID‐19 pandemic.
Authors

Research Fellow Columbia University
Sokbae is an IFS Research Fellow and a Professor at Columbia University, with an interest in Econometrics, Applied Microeconomics and Statistics.

Myung Hwan Seo

Youngki Shin

Yuan Liao
Journal article details
- DOI
- 10.1111/ecin.12919
- Publisher
- Wiley
- Issue
- July 2020
Suggested citation
Lee, S et al. (2020). 'Desperate times call for desperate measures: government spending multipliers in hard times' (2020)
More from IFS
Understand this issue

How important is the OBR forecast?
The OBR forecast will underpin the Chancellor’s decisions at the next Spring Forecast.
12 February 2025

Change in selected departmental capital budgets since 2007–08
The Ministry of Justice saw the biggest cuts to its capital budget over the 2010s, but then has seen the largest relative increases since.
11 February 2025

What is this government’s ‘theory of growth’? Nobody knows
"Shifting the performance of an entire economy requires a long-term, consistent and persistent direction." Paul Johnson writes for the Times.
20 January 2025
Policy analysis

How can policy boost productivity growth?
At this policy conference, four panels of experts will give their perspectives and recommendations on four key areas of the UK’s productivity problem.

Current budget as a share of national income: out-turn and October 2024 forecast
There has not been a sizeable current budget surplus for over twenty years.
24 March 2025

Current budget as a share of national income: out-turn and past forecasts
On average, the OBR has forecast a £23 billion current budget surplus 5 years out, but this has typically not materialised.
24 March 2025
Academic research

TaxDev collaborating with Government of Ghana on VAT, customs, and distributional analysis
Ghana Ministry of Finance officials explain how the partnership with TaxDev is helping to improve tax policy analysis
24 February 2025

A review of Ghana's value-added tax (VAT) system
The report undertakes a review of the VAT system in Ghana with a view to making recommendations for future policy action.
11 February 2025

Survey of the Ghanaian Tax System
This edition of the Survey of Ghana’s Tax System provides a comprehensive overview of the tax system as of the start of 2024.
18 November 2024