Downloads
Download working paper here
PDF | 1.18 MB
The Frisch labor supply elasticity plays a key role in many economic policy debates, but its magnitude remains controversial. Many studies estimate the Frisch elasticity using 2SLS regressions of hours changes on wage changes. But a little appreciated power asymmetry property of 2SLS causes estimates to appear spuriously imprecise when they are shifted away from the OLS bias. This makes it difficult for a 2SLS t-test to detect a true positive Frisch elasticity. We illustrate this problem in an application to NLSY97 data. We obtain an estimate of 0.60 for young men, but the t-test indicates it is insignificant. In contrast, the Anderson-Rubin (AR) test – which is both optimal and avoids the power asymmetry problem – implies the estimate is highly significant. The same power asymmetry issue that afflicts the t-test here will arise in many IV applications. Thus, we argue the AR test should be widely adopted in lieu of the 2SLS t-test.
Authors
Research Associate John Hopkins Carey Business School
Michael Keane is a Wm. Polk Carey Distinguished Professor at the John Hopkins Carey Business School.
Timothy Neal
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2024.4624
- Publisher
- Institute for Fiscal Studies
Suggested citation
Keane, M and Neal, T. (2024). Robust inference for the Frisch labor supply. 24/46. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/robust-inference-frisch-labor-supply (accessed: 4 November 2024).
More from IFS
Understand this issue
What is Labour's economic strategy?
22 July 2024
Election Special: The UK economy since 2008
3 June 2024
If you can’t see it, you can’t be it: role models influence female junior doctors’ choice of medical specialty
24 April 2024
Policy analysis
The changing educational attainment of graduate recruits to major public sector occupations
Public sector pay has been squeezed since public spending cuts began to take effect from 2011, and it looks set to be squeezed even further up to 2020. However, this comes on the back of an increase in public sector wages relative to those in the private sector during the Great Recession. There is currently significant policy interest in the extent to which continued stagnation in public sector wages will affect the ability of the public sector to recruit and retain high-quality workers, although to date little is known about the potential effects.
13 March 2017
The gender wage gap
This briefing note is the first output in a programme of work seeking to understand the gender wage gap and its relationship to poverty. Section 1 sets out what we mean by the gender wage gap, how it differs according to education level and how it has evolved over time and across generations. Section 2 provides some descriptive evidence on how the gender wage gap relates to the presence of dependent children and the employment outcomes associated with that.
23 August 2016
The impact of the UK Government's tax, welfare and minimum wage reforms in Wales
This report examines the impact of the changes to the tax and benefit system to be introduced by the UK Government between April 2015 and April 2019 in Wales and compare this to average impacts across the whole UK.
19 November 2015
Academic research
Hidden redistribution in lifetime earnings: the role of differential mortality
Life expectancy gaps between gender and income groups are large and generate notable implicit redistribution in lifetime earnings via pension systems.
9 October 2024
Identifying network ties from panel data: Theory and an application to tax competition
9 September 2024
The gender gap in household bargaining power: a revealed-preference approach
22 August 2024