Downloads

Download working paper here
PDF | 1.46 MB
Differences in life expectancy between gender and income groups are large and generate significant implicit redistribution in lifetime earnings through pension systems. We use administrative data on the universe of private sector wage earners in France to quantify these effects. We establish two main results. In terms of between gender redistribution, we find that differential mortality – life expectancy at 55 is 5.7 years higher among women than among men – reduces lifetime income inequality between men and women: absent this differential in life expectancy, the pension gap between men and women would be 72% higher, in a lifetime perspective. Second, within gender, high income earners benefit from hidden lifetime redistribution due to higher life expectancy. We find a life expectancy gradient of 7.2 years between the extremes of the distribution among men, 1.8 years among women. Among men, this hidden redistribution more than offsets the overall progressivity of the pension system.
Authors

Economist CREST, École Polytechnique de Paris

Research Ined and Centraal planbureau

Research Fellow Institut des politiques publiques (IPP)
Maxime is a Research Fellow of the IFS, and a Senior Research Economist at the Institut des Politiques Publiques since September 2017.
Working Paper details
- DOI
- 10.1920/wp.ifs.2024.4424
- Publisher
- Institute for Fiscal Studies
Suggested citation
A, Mélard and S, Rabaté and M, Tô. (2024). Hidden redistribution in lifetime earnings: the role of differential mortality. 24/44. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies. Available at: https://ifs.org.uk/publications/hidden-redistribution-lifetime-earnings-role-differential-mortality (accessed: 23 June 2025).
More from IFS
Understand this issue

How big are the UK's demographic challenges?
With birth rates at record lows, we ask what the implications are for the UK and how it might impact the public finances.
8 November 2024

Why did the French Budget fail to pass?
France’s failed budget highlights fundamental challenges with public debt, slow growth, and the need for significant reforms.
12 December 2024

We can’t have any more budgets where speculation is running wild
Rachel Reeves needs to deliver a clear statement of intent for the remainder of this government’s time in office
28 October 2024
Policy analysis

Working in your 60s: a way to stay young for some
On average, women who remained in work for longer following increases in the state pension age saw improved cognition and less physical disability.
13 May 2025

Here’s a pension tweak for nudging civil servants to work past 60
Public sector pension rules are a mess that helps neither workers nor the government. Fixing them could be a win-win.
28 April 2025

Which places have the highest standard of living?
Measuring living standards using average household spending gives a starkly different picture of regional inequalities than using average income.
11 April 2025
Academic research

The future of public pension provision in the UK: challenges and trade-offs
The UK state pension system faces significant challenges given the country’s ageing population, but it is crucial for retirement finances.
6 June 2025

Female genital cutting and the slave trade
We investigate the historical origins of female genital cutting (FGC) and how FGC is associated with the Red Sea route of the African slave trade.
10 May 2025

Interpreting Cohort Profiles of Life Cycle Earnings Volatility
We present new estimates of earnings volatility over time and the life cycle by race and human capital, using Social Security earnings.
7 May 2025